Analogue, DCC, mfx: which to choose?
A question that comes up on every forum and often holds beginners back. In short, it depends on your track and on how you want to run your trains.
The three systems
| Analogue | The transformer sets the voltage; every train on the circuit responds together. Simple and robust: ideal for getting started or for running an older collection. |
| DCC | The international digital standard (two-rail). Each locomotive has its address: independent speed, lights and sound, several trains on the same track. |
| mfx | Märklin/Trix digital (mostly three-rail). The locomotive registers itself with the Central Station automatically, with no setup. |
A simple rule
- Märklin track (3-rail AC) → Märklin controller, mfx or DCC-AC locomotives.
- Two-rail DC track (Trix, Roco, Fleischmann, Piko, etc.) → DCC, whatever the controller (Z21, multiMaus, CS, etc.).
- An analogue locomotive can almost always be converted to digital: all it needs is a decoder.
Our advice
- Beginners with children: a digital starter set, with everything matched at the factory.
- Older collection: stay analogue, or have your locomotives converted to digital one by one in our workshop.
- Sound: impressive, but keep it for your flagship locomotives rather than fitting it everywhere.